By Yongama Mvinjelwa - Fiduciary Customer Solutions Specialist
Customary marriages in South Africa hold significant cultural importance and are legally recognised under the Recognition of Customary Marriages Act 120 of 1998 (RCMA). However, the effects of a customary marriage become particularly complex upon the death of one of the spouses. Understanding these effects is essential, especially in estate planning and the administration of estates.
1. Recognition of Customary Marriages
Customary marriages in South Africa are recognised alongside civil marriages and are legally binding. For a customary marriage to be valid, it must adhere to specific requirements stipulated in the RCMA, including that:
A customary marriage is concluded when a bride is handed over to the family of the bridegroom or the bridegroom himself. The handing over of the bride is an important indication that a valid customary marriage has been concluded. At the time of handing the bride over, a celebration is held.
2. The proprietary consequences of customary marriages
A monogamous customary marriage entered into under the RCMA is in community of property, including profit and loss, unless these consequences are excluded by an antenuptial contract. A polygamous customary marriage may have a court approved written contract aimed at regulating the property system of the marriages. In absence of the contract, the marriage will be considered out of community of property.
3. Testamentary Succession
The right to freedom of testation allows a testator, in terms of a customary marriage, to draft a Will that dictates the distribution of their estate. It is important that the Will clearly address the customary marriage and any polygamous union and ensure it aligns with both customary law and statutory requirements to avoid disputes.
4. Intestate Succession
If a spouse in a customary marriage dies without a will, the estate is distributed according to the Intestate Succession Act 81 of 1987. The surviving spouse has the same rights to inherit as a spouse in a civil marriage. In a polygamous marriage, for instance, each wife is entitled to inherit from the deceased husband's estate. The estate is divided equitably among all wives and children.
In customary marriages, the executor may further face challenges in balancing statutory obligations with customary practices, especially in polygamous households. Family elders and traditional leaders may often have to be consulted in the decision-making process, particularly regarding the distribution of cattle, communal land, and other assets integral to the community's customs. The executor must navigate these dynamics carefully to honour both legal and customary expectations.
5. Challenges and Legal Disputes
Disputes often arise in the administration of estates involving customary marriages, particularly in polygamous marriages or where there is conflict between customary law and statutory law. These disputes may involve:
Legal disputes in such cases are typically resolved through litigation. The courts in South Africa have increasingly recognised the importance of customary law and have provided judgments that aim to balance customary practices with the rights of individuals under the Constitution.
6. Conclusion
The implications of Customary marriages on inheritance and the administration of an estate upon death, need to be considered. While the RCMA and other relevant legislation provide a framework for recognizing and protecting the rights of spouses in customary marriages, complexities arise due to the intersection of customary and statutory law. Understanding these effects is essential for ensuring that the rights of all parties, particularly surviving spouses, and children, are protected in accordance with the law and cultural practices.
By acknowledging both the legal framework and customary practices, South Africa continues to strive towards a legal system that respects cultural diversity while upholding the principles of equality and fairness enshrined in the Constitution.
FNB Fiduciary (Pty) Limited Registration Number 1986/003488/07- A subsidiary within the FirstRand Group of Companies. An Authorised Financial Services Provider.
